The Lie We Tell Ourselves About 401(k) Loans

Written By Nickolas Williams

When people talk about taking loans from their 401(k), it usually sounds harmless. Sometimes it even sounds smart.

“I’m paying myself back.”
“It’s my money anyway.”
“They’re gonna tax it eventually.”

On the surface, those statements feel logical. Convenient. Responsible.

But they also reveal a misunderstanding of what a 401(k) actually is and what it’s designed to do.

A 401(k) isn’t just money you own. It’s a long-term, tax-advantaged wealth-building tool meant to grow quietly over decades. When you regularly take loans from it, you don’t just pause that growth. You chip away at the very system meant to support you later in life.

And the cost is far bigger than most people realize.

“I’m Paying Myself Back” Isn’t the Win It Sounds Like

Yes, technically, when you take a 401(k) loan, you repay the balance back into your account. That’s where the explanation usually stops. And that’s where the problem begins.

What gets ignored is how the money is treated along the way.

401(k) loan repayments are made with after-tax dollars. Later, when you retire, that same money is taxed again when you withdraw it.

So the “interest you’re paying yourself” isn’t really a benefit. In many cases, it barely offsets the double taxation happening in the background. And it almost never competes with what that money could have earned if it had stayed invested in the market.

You’re not paying yourself extra. You’re just covering part of the hidden cost.

The Opportunity Cost Is the Real Damage

The biggest loss from a 401(k) loan isn’t the interest rate. It’s what your money isn’t doing while it’s gone.

While that money is out:

  • It isn’t compounding

  • It isn’t earning dividends

  • It isn’t capturing market recoveries

  • It isn’t growing tax-deferred

Compounding doesn’t pause because life gets hard. It keeps moving forward. Miss a strong year or two in the market, and that lost time doesn’t get refunded later.

Time is the one thing retirement accounts cannot replace.

Regular 401(k) Loans Are a Planning Signal

This is the uncomfortable part, but it matters.

When someone regularly takes loans from their 401(k), it often signals a lack of margin. Not a lack of effort. Not a lack of intelligence. A lack of financial buffer.

I understand hard times. I’ve lived them. Survival choices are real. But there’s a difference between a one-time emergency and a repeated pattern.

Repeated 401(k) loans often point to:

  • No emergency fund

  • Budgeting gaps

  • Lifestyle inflation

  • Little room for delayed gratification

  • Using future assets to support present habits

Do you truly know how much money is coming in versus how much is going out each pay period? Have you built buffers for inevitable disruptions, or are you using your future as the buffer?

The Job Risk Nobody Plans For

Most people assume stable employment when they take out a 401(k) loan. Life doesn’t operate on assumptions.

If you change jobs, get laid off, or lose your position, many plans require that loan to be repaid quickly. Miss that window, and the loan becomes a distribution.

That means:

  • Immediate income taxes

  • Plus a 10% penalty if you’re under 59½

What felt like a temporary solution can turn into a permanent setback at the worst possible time.

If You Have Kids, the Stakes Are Higher

If you’re raising children, this conversation gets louder.

What plans do you have in place to make their life easier than the one you lived or are currently living?

That new outfit doesn’t transfer wealth.
That car starts losing value the moment it leaves the lot.
That lifestyle doesn’t compound.

But stability does. Options do. A protected retirement does.

Repeatedly borrowing from your future limits what you’ll have to live on later and what you’ll be able to pass down, if anything at all.

Convenience Today Creates Dependence Tomorrow

Yes, a 401(k) loan can make today more comfortable.

But comfort funded by future assets often leads to:

  • Reduced retirement contributions

  • Tighter cash flow

  • Increased financial stress

  • Fewer options later in life

Eventually, many people end up depending on systems they don’t control.

And if you’ve been paying attention, those systems are anything but stable. Government shutdowns. Benefit uncertainty. Assistance programs constantly on the chopping block. People were recently worried about food assistance being delayed or reduced altogether.

Why build a future that depends on instability when you still have time to build something sturdier for yourself?

The Hard Truth, Said With Care

Taking a loan from your 401(k), especially on a regular basis, is not the best idea. Over time, it becomes an extremely costly one.

Do I understand hard times? Absolutely. I’ve lived through plenty of them. But I also learned from them. I adjusted. I delayed gratification when I could. I focused on building systems my future self wouldn’t have to undo.

If you’ve taken a 401(k) loan already, let the next one be the last. Let it be the moment that triggers a deeper reset.

Sit down and do the real work:

  • Budgeting

  • Saving

  • Investing

The real Big 3.

Yes, it may cost you the new car every few years.
It may cost you shoes, outfits, trips, and short-term flexing.

But it gains you something far more valuable.

Control.
Options.
Stability.
And the chance to stop repeating generational patterns instead of reinforcing them.

That trade is worth it.

What You Do Next Matters

If this post hit close to home, take that as information, not guilt.

You don’t fix long-term problems with short-term moves. You fix them by building systems that give you breathing room and options.

If you’re ready to stop borrowing from your future and start building one with more control, here are a few places to start:

You’ll find all of these in The Urban Profit Resource Store.

Start where you are. Use what you have. And make the move that future you won’t have to clean up.

Nickolas Williams
Next

Making a Way Out of No Way:Why Black Wealth Has Always Been Built, Not Given